Fact or Fiction: Should I Match My Kitchen Island to My Countertops?

Kitchen Remodel Wichita

When it comes to kitchen remodels, one question that often arises is whether or not you should match your kitchen island to your countertops. While some homeowners believe consistency is key, others argue that variety is better. So, what’s the truth? Our team at Southwestern Remodeling, the choice for a kitchen remodel in Wichita, Kansas, is exploring the facts and fiction surrounding kitchen countertops and islands. Learn more below!

Fact: Cohesion Is Key

Your kitchen island doesn’t have to match your countertops perfectly, but it’s still important to consider the color and material, ensuring the two complement each other in some noticeable way. Not only does this help create cohesion throughout the kitchen, but your home will appear more thought out and appeal to potential homebuyers in the future. Our experts at Southwestern Remodeling recommend choosing a similar pattern or color that complements your countertops if you choose to use an entirely different material!

Fiction: Matching is Boring

If mismatched materials make you uneasy, don’t worry; you can still opt for a kitchen island that matches your countertops! While some people may find matching countertops and islands “boring,” it all comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a more cohesive and uniform look in your kitchen, then matching may be the way to go. However, if you prefer a more eclectic or unique look, mixing and matching different materials and colors can help you achieve that.

Fact: Consider Your Overall Design Style

Your decision to match or not match your kitchen island to your countertops should also take into account your overall design style. For example, if you have a modern and minimalist kitchen, then a matching island and countertops can help reinforce that sleek and streamlined look. On the other hand, if your kitchen has a more traditional or rustic feel, then a mix of materials might help enhance that aesthetic.

Fiction: Matching is More Expensive

It’s a common misconception that matching your kitchen island to your countertops is more expensive than using different materials. While it’s true that some materials are more costly than others, the cost of your kitchen remodel will depend on many factors beyond just the materials you choose. Additionally, there are many affordable options available for both countertops and kitchen islands that can help you achieve the look you want without breaking the bank.

Final Verdict: Do What Feels Right for You

There are many different ways to design a kitchen, and matching your island to your countertops is just one option. While some designers may prefer to use contrasting materials for their kitchen islands to add visual interest to the space, matching kitchen countertops may be the final touch of cohesion you need to bring your room together. Ultimately, there’s no definitive answer about whether or not your countertops should match your kitchen island, so evaluate your different options and choose what feels suitable for you and your home!

Contact Southwestern Remodeling

Are you ready to start your kitchen remodel in Wichita? At Southwestern Remodeling, we offer free in-home consultations to all new customers. We encourage you to contact us at (316) 263-1239 to schedule yours today!